Nov
14

Arithmophobia

By Tom Sullivan

I’m still waiting to meet someone unemployed who is more worried about federal deficits than his or her own family’s. But to hear the Beltway punditocracy tell it, deficits are all we should care about.

Chris Hayes comments on a Politico piece at The Nation:

There’s one big maddening conceptual error at the heart of this piece (whether committed in good faith or bad I can’t say) which is to confuse relatively substantial pieces of domestic legislation with a spending “binge.” See, a government, like any organization, institution, or firm has expenditures and revenues. Miraculously, it can increase its expenditures, without increasing its deficit, if it also increases its revenues. This is called “deficit neutral” and it’s what the current health care bill, in all its incarnations, is.

But don’t confuse them with all those elitist, three- and four-syllable words. Government that is B-I-G is government that is B-A-D. And lawdy, what are they thinking, talking about passing deficit-neutral bills in a time of high deficits? Deficit-neutral has “deficit” right there in its name! Hayes continues:

You may object to government doing the things it’s doing. You may think the working poor should just suck it up when they get sick, or that we should subject Bangladesh to a horrific future in which it is plunged into the sea, but you can’t say that the motivation for your objection is accounting.

Of course, you can. All those zeroes. Numbers that are B-I-G are numbers that are B-A-D.

Arithmophobia.

[h/t Digby]

Categories : Economy

5 Comments

1

“I’m still waiting to meet someone unemployed who is more worried about federal deficits than his or her own family’s.”

Gordon Smith took the time to email in to “Take a Stand” on WWNC last week to opine that the rising unemployment rate is “just a lagging indicator” of an otherwise rosy economy. So, worry not!!!!

Rate this comment: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

2

Not quite, Watcher. I commented at Matt Mittan’s Facebook page. You can read the exchange here. Things certainly aren’t rosy, but it’s true that employment is a historically lagging indicator. Let’s not forget that a little over a year ago the talk was about how to prevent a global economic meltdown of unprecedented proportions.

Rate this comment: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

3

Gordon is right that employment is a lagging indicator. I just don’t know what he wanted to achieve by trying to point that out to Mittan or most of his facebook groupies. Matt doesn’t want dialogue, only controversy or make it about him. If everyone ignored him, the world (and most certainly Buncombe County) would be a better place.

It worked out fine for the Democratic candidates for Buncombe County Commissioner…they did not show up for a radio debate with their Republican challengers, and they all won seats on the Board. Not one Republican won. He doesn’t have as much influence as he pretends.

Rate this comment: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

4

I don’t know about the rest of you, but personally I’m fed up with Republican lectures on fiscal responsibility from a party that turned at 2.7 billion surplus into a trillion dollar deficit.

Rate this comment: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

5

RHS,

Not nearly as fed up as I am with lectures on fiscal responsibility from conservative Democrats. And now President Obama is getting into the act . . .

Rate this comment: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0